| Men's Hoops | |
| Joe Farroba | MASCAC Coach of the Year |
| Judah Jackson | MASCAC All-Conference Second Team |
| MASCAC Co-Player of the Week (2/22) | |
| SUNY New Paltz Tip-Off Tournament All-Tournament Team | |
| Matt McLaughlin | NEBCA Senior All-Star Game |
| MASCAC All-Conference Second Team | |
| MASCAC Player of the Week (3/1) | |
| MASCAC Tournament Most Valuable Player | |
| Nicholas Motta | NABC Division III All-Northeast Region Second Team |
| D3hoops.com All-Northeast Region Second Team | |
| ECAC Division III All-New England Second Team | |
| MASCAC Player of the Year | |
| MASCAC All-Conference First Team | |
| MASCAC Player of the Week (2/8) | |
| MASCAC Player of the Week (2/1) | |
| MASCAC Co-Player of the Week (1/25) | |
| D3hoops.com Team of the Week (1/7) | |
| MASCAC Player of the Week (1/4) | |
| Moravian Greyhound Starters Classic All-Tournament Team | |
| MASCAC Player of the Week (11/30) | |
| Women's Hoops | |
| Monica-Sabina Bharoocha | BSC D'Angelo Tip-Off Classic All-Tournament Team |
| Bridgett Casey | MASCAC Coach of the Year |
| Corey Cuddihy | MASCAC Player of the Week (1/11) |
| Brittney Chappron | MASCAC All-Conference First Team |
| D3hoops.com Team of the Week | |
| MASCAC Co-Player of the Week (1/25) | |
| MASCAC Player of the Week (1/18) | |
| Shelly DePina | MASCAC All-Conference First Team |
| Indoor Track | |
| Nicholas Ferrara | All-New England Alliance High Jump (3rd Place) |
| All-MASCAC High Jump (1st Place) | |
| Felix Mensah | All-New England Alliance 55-Meter Dash (6th Place) |
| MASCAC Track Athlete of the Week (2/1) | |
| Stephen Wahome | All-New England Alliance 3,000-Meter Run (2nd Place) |
| All-MASCAC 3,000-Meter Run (1st Place) | |
| Kevin White | All-New England Alliance 55-Meter Hurdles (5th Place) |
| Kylie Almeida | All-New England Alliance 4x400-Meter Relay (2nd Place) |
| All-MASCAC 4x400-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Colleen Davis | All-New England Alliance 4x400-Meter Relay (2nd Place) |
| All-New England Alliance 600-Meter Run (3rd Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 600-Meter Run (1st Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 4x400-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Jessica Eidinger | All-New England Alliance 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) |
| All-New England Alliance One-Mile Run (6th Place) | |
| All-New England Alliance 1,000-Meter Run (7th Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Melissa Harris | All-New England Alliance 800-Meter Run (8th Place) |
| Sarah Lagasse | All-New England Alliance 4x400-Meter Relay (2nd Place) |
| All-New England Alliance 800-Meter Run (4th Place) | |
| All-New England Alliance 3,000-Meter Run (4th Place) | |
| All-New England Alliance One-Mile Run (8th Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 800-Meter Run (1st Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 3,000-Meter Run (1st Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 4x400-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Carissa Penney | All-New England Alliance 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) |
| All-MASCAC 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Brittany Robinson | All-New England Alliance 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) |
| All-MASCAC 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Carrie Robitaille | All-New England Alliance 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) |
| All-New England Alliance 4x400-Meter Relay (2nd Place) | |
| All-New England Alliance 55-Meter Hurdles (6th Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 4x400-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| All-MASCAC 4x800-Meter Relay (1st Place) | |
| Taylor Smith | All-New England Alliance 55-Meter Dash (7th Place) |
| Wrestling | |
| Zachary Bates | NWCA Division III Scholar All-American |
| All-NEWA 174 pounds (2nd Place) | |
| Pilgrim Wrestling League Scholar-Athlete All-Star | |
| Frank Cammisa | NCAA Division III Championships Participant (157 Pounds) |
| All-NEWA 157 Pound (1st Place) | |
| Pilgrim Wrestling League First Team All-Star | |
| Andrew Frazer | All-NEWA 197 Pounds (4th Place) |
| John Marsh | NCAA Division III All-American - 149 Pounds (5th Place) |
| NCAA Division III Championships Participant (149 Pounds) | |
| NEWA Co-Most Outstanding Wrestler of the Year | |
| All-NEWA 149 Pounds (1st Place) | |
| Pilgrim Wrestling League First Team All-Star | |
| Pilgrim Wrestling League Wrestler of the Week (2/17) | |
| NEWA Wrestler of the Week (11/23) | |
| Ethan Raymond | All-NEWA 165 Pounds (3rd Place) |
| Pilgrim Wrestling League Second Team All-Star | |
| Pilgrim Wrestling League Wrestler of the Week (1/25) |