| Player | Years | Points | ||
| Mark Gonsalves | 1995-99 | 1,907 | ||
| Joe O'Connor | 1989-93 | 1,784 | ||
| Bruce Higgins | 1993-97 | 1,727 | ||
| Ray Carvalho | 1956-60 | 1,636 | ||
| Dan Hunt | 1992-96 | 1,563 | ||
| Ryan Carney | 2015-16, 2017-20 | 1,551 | ||
| Michael Lofton | 2011-15 | 1,504 | ||
| Tom Cuddihy | 2004-08 | 1,482 | ||
| Judah Jackson | 2007-11 | 1,481 | ||
| Joe Wise | 1970-73 | 1,451 | ||
| Nicholas Motta | 2007-11 | 1,434 | ||
| Mike Morris | 1993-96 | 1,427 | ||
| John Hickey | 1988-92 | 1,425 | ||
| Rayshon Ward | 2016-20 | 1,377 | ||
| Peter Santos | 2001-05 | 1,302 | ||
| Mark Dias | 1982-86 | 1,282 | ||
| David Rukstalis | 2002-06 | 1,271 | ||
| John McSharry | 1971-75 | 1,230 | ||
| Paul Sargent | 1953-57 | 1,200 | ||
| Harry Grabert | 1998-02 | 1,189 | ||
| Ken Brennan | 1961-65 | 1,179 | ||
| Billy English | 1976-80 | 1,179 | ||
| Roland Millien | 2005-09 | 1,160 | ||
| Rocky DeAndrade | 2014-18 | 1,150 | ||
| Sean Carey | 1987-90 | 1,146 | ||
| Rich Brennan | 1970-74 | 1,129 | ||
| Derek Savas | 1998-02 | 1,063 | ||
| Terry Riley | 1976-80 | 1,029 | ||
| Devere Morris | 1980-84 | 1,029 | ||
| Bill Scigliano | 1980-84 | 1,020 |